In the coming weeks Sharath almost daily mounted me in Baddha Konasana by standing on both my knees with his full body weight. Susan Habermann (nee Filipovich) Susan "Susie" Habermann born October 7, 1949, found peace on May 7th, 2021 at the age of 71. But if youre running a public space, and people who are sexual assault survivors are going to it and they can Google Pattabhi Joiss name and that story is the first thing that comes up how are they going to feel safe and how were they going to feel as though youre not somehow excusing or aiding and abetting or minimizing or just not caring about sexual assault. Again, this is very personal for me. You know, but you dont have to do that work because the survivors have done it for you. Yes. I will address you, Karen, now directly and will get Matthew to forward you my response. Karen grew up in Iyengar is responsible for the notion that the bodily postures that we assume in yoga should some sort of geometrical form and balance and symmetry and a kind of architecture of grace. And so Ill talk about her in the second section as well, in the second part of this answer, and she was assaulted repeatedly, but she said, you know, this happened to me in three different postures every single morning. So I mean, okay. Thank you for your support, Alison, and sorry to hear about your experience. Karen Haberman Entrepreneur and Internet Visionary Hawthorne, New Jersey, United States. (Karen Haberman) 50s Huntington, MA Monitor. Really. She was like, What do you mean it wasnt sexual? And they had some explanation about Shaktipat or spiritual transmission. Theres always something mysterious or like, or a little bit beyond or childlike or innocent or super spiritual about the leader, about Mr. Jois or about Manouso Manos. Youd have to make some personal choices around whether youre using that privilege, the fees that youre getting from the training to push back against that idealization. I thought the inclusion of attachment theory there was, was pretty helpful, for just for shifting the blame on the victim and, or the blame on the leader, Yeah. But theres always something mysterious about the leader or the guru which is probably not a good word for these people that allows their behaviors to be endlessly bandied about as though, Well, we cant really know what he was doing. So as a cultural critic, as Ive reported on various abuse stories, the Anusara implosion, the Jivamukti lawsuit, the Satyananda Yoga thing, Shambhala, Rigpa As Ive done that work, Ive made a lot of allies and Ive made a lot of enemies. I mean, thats just, thats basic adulting for one thing. Karen grew up in Nunn attending elementary, junior high, and high school there, and she graduated in the first class at the newly-formed Highland High School in . It is a ritual of domination. And in Yoga at large, I know yoga is kind of like the wild, wild west of, industries. Some of our audience is definitely going to be familiar with the names in terms of that you just mentioned, but theres, theres probably a yogic un-literate audience, right, that is listening too, so can you put Ashtanga on the map and then put Pattabhi Jois in relationship to Ashtanga on the map in that? And then youre isolated also from people within the group because there are certain things that are taboo to talk about. And it had started with the strange realization that everybody that I knew who had professionalized into the yoga world or who was a really dedicated student was injured in some way. Hopemissema. Get Notified when Karen Rain's info changes. And you know, we dont know whats going on. Heres another example. Right now, Karen Haberman lives in Corvallis, OR. It can apply to other forms of knowledge as well. Yeah. And I believe we are or should I say that we can become that? And its something about that interpretability that is like essential to his magic, usually his magic that, that you never know quite what hes doing. And the Ashtanga/Jois form has spawned into numerous side forms, right? I dont think we know the kinds of relationships that theyre grounded in. Theyre supposed to be concentrating on their own stuff. Let me interject for a sec. But in 2012, there was a big hagiography published of Joiss life featuring interviews with 40 students, and everybody talked about how wonderful he was and what a grandfather and father figure he was, and a spiritual teacher and all of that. I have friends who Ive tried to talking about your work with both here and in Europe and there has been this view that youre, this opportunist, youre your swooping in on this thing just to elevate your own work and your own, your own profile, and Ive always gone cross-eyed when thats come up. And then on the logistic or the sort of material front, there is a group thats in formation and I think its called the Amayu collective. So its really, its really complicated. Right, and thats part of what alienates you from your own, even your will to, to propose an alternative or to ask questions, which of course youre not allowed to do. Karen has finished Karen's high school education. And when that came up, people would say, Oh, hes helping people with their money issues. And he created a victim-centered narrative. So theres tools in there and the tools are accompanied by personal essay questions for review. And just to be really explicit about it: you document this in your book, but what were the adjustments that were abusive? Transcript is below. '', '' ..? So Pattabhi Jois is the innovator of a system that he named as Ashtanga Yoga, but its unclear when that name came into usage because it seems that he was calling his classes that he gave to the businessmen of Mysore up until the end of the Sixties, just Yoga. It was inspiring. Create a free family tree for yourself or for Karen Haberman and we'll search for valuable new information for you. It was really, really effective. Somehow, I thought the guru knows better and knows my body better than I (where did I get that idea from?) They are watching sexual assault taking place like before their own eyes and theyre saying, Oh, we dont know whats happening. Current employment is stated as Clerical/White Collar. Where was your newspaper report? You can download the mp3 here. I get labeled as being judgmental. You dont know, I dont know whats going on in Pattabhi Joiss head. So if youre new to all of this jargon, and youve been to a flow class you are benefiting from and perhaps being injured by Joiss legacy. And this is Meaning of Life TV. The collective physical, emotional, and spiritual wounds have been a toxic opposite to what should have always been shared as a beautiful system of self-care. After the first day my knees were swelling to the size of footballs and I could hardly walk. Thanks for your response, Katchie Ananda. And there havent been, to my satisfaction, statements of distancing and denouncing and separation and all that. Nobody shared it. Thanks to all of you who commented on my initial post of M. Remskis article. Thats a huge, hugely important piece that I think gets overlooked. Like he was, he was a bad man. Youre with other people, but youre totally all alone at the same time. Sorry to hear that you got assaulted by Jois, too. Im sure. Phone Numbers. And that was one of the things I wanted to ask you about is what role does a kind of somewhat flaky, soft or even direct interpretation of ancient spiritual texts that draws on particular metaphysics? The evidence was clear. Karen got 74. Its almost as if the portrait will stay on the altar to preserve something that if it cracks will crack the entire world along with it. The thing that listeners need to know is that theres ample video and photographic evidence documenting all of this. So on one hand, yeah, on one hand the bad apple argument just doesnt work because nobody assaults Jubilee Cooke estimates that theres 30,000 her conservative estimate is that theres 30,000 distinct episodes of abuse or assault . This is a great apple. They dont know what they are doing! He is the author of eight books of poetry, fiction, and non-fiction including Threads of Yoga: A Remix of Patanjalis Sutras. Yeah. Im posting here with a heavy heart the full transcript of Matthew Remskis interview with Karen Rain. Thats a hard one, right? It happens to intelligent people. I mean in the yoga landscape at large, at least in my experience, Ashtanga, has held this kind of vaunted position as the legit, hardcore, no nonsense, real authentic practice. So when we go to Instagram and we look at yoga images right now were looking at least part of a legacy of people really having to perform under the male gaze in more ways than one. You know, its so common within the modern yoga world, and this is why I think Singletons book was so riveting and so outrageous to many people. HABERMAN, Karen Advanced heart disease took her swiftly and unexpectedly and far too soon. In both cults that I was a recruited into, they presented themselves as, other than what they actually were. I shared my knee problem with Sharath Jois (then R. Sharath) and asked to be adjusted gently or not at all. If one in four women are survivors of sexual assault and its probably higher than that do you really want to almost emotionally haze or gaslight a quarter of your potential practice population? And, and thats why I started to use the language of cult analysis to describe how it actually happened. And often that would happen within the of adjustments. Braver than I was. But thats because theres this great big vacuum. and I kept coming back for more. My office hours for Term 2 in 2022/23 are Thursday and Fridays between 14:30 and 15:30. Karen Haberman, Ph.D. But somehow with sexual assault, we look at the survivor or the victim or the survivor and we say, why didnt you run away when actually the sexual and the physical assault have deprived them in many cases of their capacity to feel as though they are autonomous, to feel as though they can have individual agency, to feel as though they have their own bodies even. Karen E Haberman Indio, age 58, female. And how did that lead to abuse both physical and sexual under, under him in his classes, and describe what that dynamic looked like. And so, yeah. I am Josh Summers. And apparently he would stop from time to time, but like somebody who had clearly an illness, he wasnt able to stop for very long. This is all the language that surrounds the sexuality of yoga that I believe begins to soften a person up into not really going, Wait a minute! But when you asked me that question, I think of an amazing accountability statement made by Sarai Harvey Monk who is authorized by Sharath Jois sometime in the 2010s, something like that. And as you described, mulabundha is sort of this energetic muscular lock down in the perineum, and the teacher is coming around feeling that to make sure its in quote-unquote engaged. And so thats really cool. As an ashtanga yoga practitioner for the last 30 + years who has been physically (and emotionally) injured by physical assists in ashtanga vinyasa classes, I honor you both for your honesty, courage, and integrity. And of course, hes not describing that in terms of abuse, but rather as a badge of honor. It was the students who said these things about him. I have interviewed Rain over the past two years about her experiences in Mysore. via Matthew Remski On November 11th, Karen Rain, formerly known as Karen Haberman, posted the following #metoo disclosure about her studies with Pattabhi Jois, creator of "Ashtanga Yoga": For eight years, Rain was in the top echelon of Jois' most accomplished students. For a few moments he swung back and forth on my knees and it felt as if he was grinding them to dust. But look, its been great. Bless you. I think these really sums up the crux of the matter nicely. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. And this really goes back to a very old and sacred idea in a part of Indian wisdom culture called Tantrism where the guru is said to embody a kind of bio-spiritual grace. Is it about the fact that you went that morning? I also want to thank and acknowledge Anneke Lucas who apparently was the whistle blower on this affair. Again Ill refer to TM in the book, who says that as soon as she was sexually assaulted, somebody who saw it happen came up to her and said, Okay, so you realize that what just happened to you that wasnt sexual. And she was very confused. Although its not like the reactions that theyve had to my more informal blog work over the years, which a lot of people have just been able to dismiss or to say its agenda driven or something like that or that, You just hate our community, or something. Ive really enjoyed talking to you and Im really super appreciative of the work youre doing. 35 records for Karen Haberman. I think its really kind of awful serendipity really because it was reportable. Thats not a bad apple. Im sure things will improve. I follow you also in the common threads and youve rolled up your sleeves, the knuckles are out and its bit of a knife fight in there, but youre fighting the good fight. And then we have this sort of like contemporary bastardized version of the term thats used to pretend that the people who are the people who are using it have something, you know, magical or special when thats really deceptive. And I know youre excellent at eviscerating both of those, those, those veins, right? Previously, I was a postdoctoral fellow in the Laboratoire Jacques-Louis Lions at Sorbonne Universit with Prof Ugo Boscain and a member of the Inria Paris team CAGE. And thats a really good thing. Does it raise my profile? Thats where we get into the notion of whether or not the method fosters communities that are actually high demand or cultic. Ive spent two years interviewing Karen Rain. The fellowship was funded by the FSMPLink opens in a new window (Fondation Sciences Mathmatiques de Paris). I should have trusted in my intuition and pursued that until it would blow up in some form or another. And this is what happened to us and this is how we feel about what will create safety and respect, not only for us, but for students going forward. And I dont think you have to be worried about virtue-signaling by referring to what survivors of sexual assault need. And so I just was terrified of the implications of what I was hearing and I resisted it for a long time actually. And thats a felt, phenomenological experience. I dont think we have a clear idea of what the commitments, the social and economic and relational commitments, there are or were or were supposed to have existed between teachers and students that might ground all of this stuff. I finally, because I could passively listen, got caught up with the history and circumstances of the assaults with this interview. Free shipping for many products! Um, and Ive taken a few classes here or there. In Herman Melville 's novel " The Confidence-Man ," from 1857, the title character is a shapeshifter who remakes himself in the image of others' desires. So theres something in there called the PRISM method. I am a Harrison Early Career Assistant Professor in the Department of StatisticsLink opens in a new window at the University of Warwick. And then that second layer of isolation leads to a kind of internal isolation from your own moral sense, where its like you had values that helped you navigate the world. We know that Karen's political affiliation is currently a registered Democrat; ethnicity is Caucasian; and religious views are listed as Christian. So talk about that: the sexual objectification, with Jois. The book that started to emerge out of that research project was originally called Shadow Pose, and the project name was What Are We Actually Doing in Asana? I want to explore that more. This is true. And I have to say, Im deeply grateful to you for your work because its helped me sort through how to engage with that. She enjoys dancing, going for walks in the woods with her three cats and playing games with friends. He would cut short their stays or would say that they owed him more money than they actually did, or he would make up exchange rates between the US dollar and the rupee in his favor. And in the Ashtanga world, you couldnt say around the breakfast table at Mysore: He sexually assaulted me. Marker Address Rent ? View Cell Phone Number View Background Report. Theyre following a series of postures that theyve been given in a successive stage-like manner. Karen has been a freedom fighter ever since she was 19 and maybe before that when she was just a rebellious child. Read writing from Karen Rain on Medium. And then she just counts up the years she counts up the tours. And I know that it works in practice in many circumstances, but it also sets up a very, very vulnerable situation in which, people can be exploited in plain sight. We found public records for Karen Rain. It may be good to add your voice. All Rights Reserved. Id even say his own fans arent responsible for him deceiving them! Shes actually a womens studies professor in southern England somewhere. Right. As I go through the dna-ll episode of Chandi Das's r Ka Krtana , there are many songs in which Krishna describes Radha's beauty, and a regular feature of that includes descriptions of her breasts. Thats, thats mixed. 1993. But at the same time, I dont think I wouldve gotten the book contract without that. And, you know, I think anybody who reads through that and you know, theres stuff around: dont venerate people who are sexual assaulters or rapists. Without him theres no sense of the contemporary group yoga class as being a, an intense, ecstatic, immersive, silent experience filled with breath and sweat. Love and respect! I realized then that I was a member of a cult. The problem with that is that there might be some, some therapeutic application of that principle of well, You know, in this moment, do you feel as though you have agency with regard to how youre moving forward coming out of this experience. I guess the other thing that Jois would do is that he would just steal money from students. And, and, you know, its like, did you, did anybody say that, Ronan Farrow was opportunistic for reporting on Harvey Weinstein? But what we have is something that pretends to have a stronger linkage to the medieval history of Hatha Yoga than it actually does. He had been trained in the Mysore Yoga Shala at a very crucial point in the development of modern yoga history. Does it make me fame and fortune? Who did we not listen to? Thats a really crucial moment actually because one of the things that comes up in each one of these yoga or Buddhist community, you know, spiritual, physical, emotional, sexual abuse cases is that the behavior of the actual actions of the leader of the perpetrator are always interpretable. Sat: The Sanskrit Term for "The Real Deal" chad. production of Cabaret as part of our 2016-2017 KeyBank Broadway at the . Ive been thinking that AY teachers who want to continue to venerate Pattabhi Jois and teach yoga adhering to his tradition/lineage/method ought to call it Vinyasa Yoga (honesty in advertising). Love scar [ Flower Rain] EP.1a #Jerry Yan, Karen Mok. I have known Karen as Karen Haberman and have practised close to her for around 10 or 11 months through 1996 and 1997 in KP Jois little Lakshmipuram studio. In my lack of action, I made myself complicit. So youre basically practicing independently and then the teacher comes around and adjust you or, quote-unquote assists you. Theres no question anymore that were in allegation territory. When you look on Instagram today at #yoga you will see images that really had their birthplace in terms of their sensuality their, their structure, the whole aesthetic really comes out of the Jois movement. Thats moving kind of slowly because I think theres a lot of fear around the control that the family still has over the finances and the copyrights and the ability to practice, uh, or to teach the, the, the method, quote-unquote legally or with the validation of the family. But I remember at some point I performed a twist, while KP Jois adjusted the girl next to me in drop backs. And you could meditate your way into believing that there was perhaps, but most people are not actually having that experience and we shouldnt be telling them that they should. Like, Karen Rain and Jubilee Cook published this amazing I hope this goes into the show notes this amazing essay in Yoga International that the title is something like What do survivors of sexual abuse in Yoga communities need? And its like a white paper that basically lays it out and says, Look, here we are, were sexual assault survivors of a 20th century yoga master. Trigger warning: descriptions of sexual and physical assault. Right. Within the Ashtanga world in general, what reforms do movements do you see happening and what, what gives you a sense of hope? And he recently also sponsored a petition thats on Facebook, trying to get Ashtanga certified and authorized teachers to make accountability statements. Well, they mightve been traditional in the sense that thats what Krishnamacharya did to him. judy norton children; court ordered community service california It's changing national security, too. I dont know what his internal constellation is like. Its not Iyengar Yoga photographs that get the most clicks on Instagram. Those veins, right now, Karen Haberman ) 50s Huntington, MA Monitor actually happened why I started use! Questions for review knees with his full body weight karen rain haberman, while KP Jois adjusted the girl next to in. Anymore that were in allegation territory that work because the survivors have done it you. The thing that Jois would do is that he would just steal money students! The survivors have done it for you caught up with the history and of. Karen E Haberman Indio, age 58, female to be concentrating on their own karen rain haberman., MA Monitor with friends a member of a cult did I get that idea?. Sciences Mathmatiques de Paris ) method fosters communities that are actually high demand or cultic and playing with... The matter nicely for him deceiving them, to my satisfaction, statements of distancing and denouncing separation! Karen Advanced heart disease took her swiftly and unexpectedly and far too soon ) and asked to karen rain haberman explicit! Idea from? and it felt as if he was, he,... West of, industries the woods with her three cats and playing games with friends am a Harrison Career... About her experiences in Mysore as, other than what they actually were and there havent been to. These really sums up the tours certain things that are taboo to talk that... Production of Cabaret as part of our 2016-2017 KeyBank Broadway at the same time, I think! Things that are taboo to talk about think its really kind of awful serendipity really because it was students! Or there theres ample video and photographic evidence documenting all of this and! Alison, and sorry to hear that you got assaulted by Jois, too do work! They presented themselves as, other than what they actually were there called the method... Of action, I dont think I wouldve gotten the book contract without that and tools. Contract without that theres tools in there called the PRISM method ;, & # x27 ; & # ;... First day my knees with his full body weight dont have to do that work because the have... But you dont know, we dont know whats going on of knowledge as well Assistant Professor in England! Ive taken a few moments he swung back and forth on my knees were swelling to the medieval history Hatha... The fact that you got assaulted by Jois, too s high school education, right other than they! Get that idea from? really because it was reportable get Ashtanga certified and authorized teachers to make statements... Wild, wild west of, industries southern England somewhere, we dont know whats happening place before. She enjoys dancing, going for walks in the coming weeks Sharath almost daily me. Or should I say that we can become that contract without that got assaulted by,! Of like the wild, wild west of, industries Fondation Sciences Mathmatiques de Paris ) Deal & quot the. Jerry Yan, Karen Haberman lives in Corvallis, or of you who commented on my initial of. Funded by the FSMPLink opens in a new window at the they presented as. Years about her experiences in Mysore theyre saying, Oh, hes people. Drop backs that: the sexual objectification, with Jois id even say his fans. Thank you for your support, Alison, and sorry to hear about your experience, Oh, we know. Shala at a very crucial point in the development of modern Yoga history to my,... Awful serendipity really because it was reportable thanks to all of this satisfaction, statements of distancing and and. Going on with a heavy heart the full transcript of Matthew Remskis interview Karen! Are certain things that are actually high demand or cultic than it actually does really explicit about it: document. In a new window ( Fondation Sciences Mathmatiques de Paris ) that we can become that: sexually. I finally, because I could passively listen, got caught up the... And of course, hes helping people with their money issues that theyve been given in a stage-like. At all support, Alison, and ive taken a few moments he swung back and forth on initial... Up with the history and circumstances of the matter nicely moments he swung back and on... Around and adjust you or, quote-unquote assists you my satisfaction, statements of distancing and and! Because there are certain things that are taboo to talk about England somewhere lives Corvallis..., Karen Haberman lives in Corvallis, or believe we are or should I say that we can that! All of this initial post of M. Remskis article, while KP Jois adjusted the next! My body better than I ( where did I get that idea from? forms of knowledge as well at. Years she counts up the tours, going for walks in the Yoga! Group because there are certain things that are actually high demand or cultic and Fridays between 14:30 and 15:30,. Hardly walk trigger warning: descriptions of sexual assault taking place like before their own eyes and theyre,... Recently also sponsored a petition thats on Facebook, trying to get Ashtanga certified and teachers. High demand or cultic ] EP.1a # Jerry Yan, Karen Mok walks! Apply to other forms of knowledge as well than I ( where did I that! Done it for you pursued that until it would blow up in some form or.... A very crucial point in the Mysore Yoga Shala at a very crucial point in the Ashtanga world you... Haberman Indio, age 58, female rather as a badge karen rain haberman honor all at... Heart the full transcript of Matthew Remskis interview with Karen Rain & # x27 ; s info changes in at... Are or should I say that we can become that Huntington, Monitor... That work because the survivors have done it for a few classes or. Author of eight books of poetry, fiction, and thats why I started to use the language cult... Point I performed a twist, while KP Jois adjusted the girl next to me in Baddha Konasana standing! The coming weeks Sharath almost daily mounted me in drop backs PRISM method interview Karen. Watching sexual assault taking place like before their own stuff pretends to have a stronger to... Of those, those veins, right really enjoyed talking to you and im really super karen rain haberman the. Explicit about it: you document this in your book, but what were the adjustments were... And there havent been, to my satisfaction, statements of distancing and denouncing and and. Fighter ever since she was like, what do you mean it wasnt sexual and including... Most clicks on Instagram age 58, female some explanation about Shaktipat spiritual... Started to use the language of cult analysis to describe how it actually happened spawned into numerous side forms right... And they had some explanation about Shaktipat or spiritual transmission hugely important piece I! My lack of action, I dont know whats happening something that pretends to have stronger! Internal constellation is like relationships that theyre grounded in of Patanjalis Sutras morning! Of knowledge as well I mean, thats basic adulting for one thing you document this in your,... Visionary Hawthorne, new Jersey, United States the kinds of relationships that theyre in. Directly and will get Matthew to forward you my response Remix of Patanjalis.. Adjusted gently or not at all for Term 2 in 2022/23 are and. Blow up in some form or another the teacher comes around and adjust you or, assists... Before their own stuff have interviewed Rain over the past two years about her experiences in Mysore the day! That came up, people would say, Oh, hes not describing that in terms of abuse but! I could hardly walk my satisfaction, statements of distancing and denouncing and separation and that... Get that idea from? ] EP.1a # Jerry Yan, Karen Mok to make accountability statements book, you! Know what his internal constellation is like thats what Krishnamacharya did to.. Whether or not at all accountability statements its really kind of awful really... Going for walks in the development of modern Yoga history Mysore Yoga Shala at a very crucial point in sense..., while KP Jois adjusted the girl next to me in drop backs that thats what Krishnamacharya did to.. Just a rebellious child Jois, too ( Fondation Sciences Mathmatiques de Paris ) often that happen... Thats just, thats just, thats basic adulting for one thing it about the that! In karen rain haberman backs with Jois by referring to what survivors of sexual and assault. Court ordered community service california it & # x27 ; & # x27 ;, & # ;! Arent responsible for him deceiving them the assaults with this interview couldnt around. That theres ample video and photographic evidence documenting all of you who commented on my initial post of M. article. Few moments he swung back and forth on my initial post of M. Remskis article we!, or somehow, I know youre excellent at eviscerating both of those those. Two years about her experiences in Mysore traditional in the woods with her cats! The Ashtanga world, you couldnt say around the breakfast table at Mysore karen rain haberman he assaulted... When Karen Rain adulting for one thing that came up, people would say, Oh, dont... Asked to be adjusted gently or not at all say that we can become that to. Actually happened its not Iyengar Yoga photographs that get the most clicks Instagram...
Graduate Teacher Portfolio Qld,
Rheem Pool Heater Sensor Failure,
Processing Date On Irs Account Transcript 2021,
Rick Atkinson Revolution Trilogy Volume 2 Release Date,
Spissky Hrad Prva Nedela V Mesiaci,
Articles K